18. November 2005 • David Boyle
Email this article
Not to stir up the pot, but the pot is already stirred; folks, apparently including the publishers, are complaining about this year’s UM “Vagina Monologues” show possibly discriminating against white women by trying to get an all women-of-color cast. (As per the Michigan Daily, etc.)
I have no problem (nor should anyone?) with a mostly women-of-color cast for a change. Artistic latitude, or artistic integrity, allows directors to cast an African-American woman as Rosa Parks, after all, rather than having to cast a 400-pound white man as Parks for the sake of “diversity”! Still, if NO white women are cast at all…
I am concerned how this could look vis-a-vis the affirmative action struggle, which is supposed to be about integration, not exclusion. (I support affirmative action, of course.) Racial exclusion could even, say, constitute violation of MSA bylaws (and city, county, state, or national laws), not to mention the problem found at
http://www.suntimes.com/output/news/cst-nws-siu11.html#, the Chicago Sun-Times article “U.S. accuses SIU of anti-white bias” from a week ago, which shows that the U.S. Justice Department is suing Southern Illinois University for programs that supposedly discriminate against whites. (I’m not saying the Bushies SHOULD do this, but they’re doing it.)
The directors could always practice “affirmative action” and be willing to cast at least a few white women (maybe in the roles traditionally taken by women of color…), for the sake of keeping the cast diverse, and avoiding charges of illegal racial exclusion, perhaps? (I’m not even suggesting at the moment, that transgender people be included too, though transgendered folks can always make their case if they like…) Would such inclusion and diversity really destroy this year’s production of the Monologues? Just wondering.
« Previous Article Tree City Sparkles Tree Lighting Ceremony
Next Article GM to cut 30,000 American jobs by 2008 »
—David Boyle Nov. 20 '05 - 12:03AM #
i wonder how the author (eve ensler) sees the issue.
—peter honeyman Nov. 21 '05 - 02:48PM #
I’ll be happy to see increased representation of women of color, of course. If that can be done without alienating anybody, all the better…..
—David Boyle Nov. 21 '05 - 04:35PM #
> aren’t sued by the Bushies!!
Hmmm—don’t like the sound of that phrase—sounds like some kind vagina-centered sectarianism (the ‘bushies’ vs the…uh…you fill in the blank). A bit like the Judean People’s Front vs the People’s Front of Judea.
But if we’re going to have a VM-related controversy in Ann Arbor, I think it would be more amusing to have a visit from ‘Testacles’:
http://www.nationalreview.com/comment/sommers200505020808.asp
—mw Nov. 21 '05 - 04:38PM #
National Review article was scary. Still, you can’t deny VM has a quasi-pornographic aura to it, by definition. And that may not be a good thing.
—David Boyle Nov. 21 '05 - 07:42PM #
, sez ”...Are we really so alienated from each other on this campus — dare I say segregated — that even something as inclusive as “The Vagina Monologues” must become exclusive? Are we really so divided as a student body that we must sacrifice Ensler’s vision of female solidarity in the name of race?....I fear this year’s production of “The Vagina Monologues” has widened the chasm between white women and women of color on this campus, something that we cannot afford here at the University.”
This echoes some the things I said above.
The controversy continues…
—David Boyle Nov. 22 '05 - 07:44PM #
I am a white woman. I am a white woman who has produced the VMs. I am not so foolish that I do not understand how this is difficult for white women on this campus who wish to express themselves by acting in the VMs. However, I think it is time that we dealt with this difficulty and listened to the women of color in our community. I know that if we truly listen to them the things we will gain from watching their show will be just as valuable, if not more than, as if we were on stage with them. Embrace this chance to learn and grow!
—Elizabeth Campbell Nov. 27 '05 - 02:50AM #
—Elizabeth Campbell Nov. 28 '05 - 03:34AM #
—John Q Nov. 28 '05 - 03:20PM #
—Elizabeth Campbell Nov. 29 '05 - 04:47AM #
I can’t believe that past discrimination has only extended to the casting of roles on stage. Surely women of color have been excluded from the powers of position in the world of drama and theater. Shouldn’t the white women directing and producing the show “step back” and allow women of color to assume those roles?
—John Q Nov. 29 '05 - 06:25AM #
—Elizabeth Campbell Nov. 30 '05 - 07:46PM #